Stephanie Wilson

By: Stephanie Wilson on January 3rd, 2024

Print/Save as PDF

Understanding Freight Fraud: Types, Trends, and Real-World Case Studies

Freight/Shipping Trends | Agency Ownership | Business Advice | Logistics | Hostage Load | Transportation | Best Practices | Agent Program | Safety | Freight Management

As we step into the new year, it's a timely reminder that while seasons change, some challenges remain constant. Among these is the issue of freight fraud, a persistent and significant concern in the logistics industry. This threat doesn't ebb and flow with the seasons; it's a year-round challenge that requires continual vigilance. Reports like those from CargoNet highlight the severity of the situation, with cargo theft and related fraudulent activities costing the logistics industry hundreds of millions of dollars annually.

This blog post sheds light on the various shapes and forms of freight fraud, unpacking the latest trends and their implications for businesses. Armstrong is here to guide you through recognizing, understanding, and effectively combating these risks, ensuring you stay alert and protected every step of the way.

Unpacking Freight Fraud: Types and Trends

Over the years, logistics scams have evolved in scale and sophistication. The first step to fighting fraud is to understand its various forms and the current trends shaping it.

Types of Freight Fraud

  1. Phishing - 1.3.24Phishing Scams: These are deceptive practices where fraudsters masquerade as legitimate businesses to extract sensitive information from shippers or carriers. They often use spoofed emails that appear to be from trusted sources, prompting unsuspecting victims to provide login credentials or financial information.
  2. Identity Theft: Here, imposters create fake profiles, mimicking reputable carriers or shippers. They use these profiles to secure contracts and then disappear with the freight or demand payments for deliveries they never intend to make.
  3. Payment Fraud: This type of fraud occurs when criminals gain access to a company's payment systems. They direct funds to their accounts through various schemes, such as invoice fraud or rerouting payment information.
  4. Fictitious Pickups: These happen when unauthorized individuals, posing as legitimate carriers, pick up cargo shipments. By the time the fraud is detected, the cargo has often vanished, leaving shippers and legitimate carriers at a loss.
  5. Shipment Diversion: Also known as "rerouting fraud," this involves a scammer intercepting a shipment in transit and redirecting it to an alternative location. They often exploit gaps in the verification process of shipment handovers.
  6. Load Pilferage: This subtle fraud involves the theft of part of the cargo. It can often go undetected until the recipient notices missing items, as documentation is manipulated to cover up the discrepancy.

Trends in Freight Fraud

The frequency and sophistication of freight fraud have been on an uptick. A few notable trends include:

  • Increased Digital Vulnerabilities: With the logistics industry's growing reliance on digital platforms, cybercriminals have more opportunities to exploit system vulnerabilities. The rise of remote work has further expanded the attack surface.
  • Greater Organizational Involvement: Modern freight fraud schemes often involve multiple players, indicating a shift from lone wolves to organized groups. This shift allows for more complex and convincing fraud operations.
  • Cross-Border Shipping - 1.3.24Cross-border Challenges: As supply chains become more global, fraudsters capitalize on the increased difficulty of tracing and prosecuting international crime.
  • Data as a Target: Criminals are increasingly interested in hijacking data, not just physical goods. With valuable information on the line, the stakes are higher, and the impact of fraud can extend far beyond the immediate loss of goods.
  • Exploitation of Industry Disruptions: Fraudsters have been quick to leverage disruptions caused by global events such as the COVID-19 pandemic. They prey on the vulnerabilities caused by rapid changes in supply and demand and the resulting chaos in supply chains.
  • Rising Costs: The financial impact of freight fraud is escalating. Not only are the direct costs of stolen goods and ransom payments increasing, but the indirect costs, including insurance premiums and investment in security measures, are also climbing.

As businesses adapt to these continually evolving scams, they must update their security measures and stay vigilant to protect their cargo, reputation, and bottom line.

Case Studies: When Freight Fraud Strikes

Fraud within the freight industry disrupts operations and has lasting effects on financial stability and industry reputation. By examining real-world situations, businesses can better understand fraudsters' methods and develop more robust defenses. One recent case study involves the misuse of the DAT load board, a widely utilized freight-matching service in the transportation industry.

The DAT Load Board Phishing Scheme

Cybercriminals crafted a sophisticated phishing operation targeting users of DAT. The scam unfolded as follows:

  1. Scam Email - 1.3.24Deceptive Emails: The perpetrators crafted emails designed to mimic communications from DAT. These messages appeared to include a FreightGuard report, a service feature familiar to DAT's users.
  2. Counterfeit Website: The emails contained a link to respond to the supposed report, directing recipients to a fraudulent website——which closely resembles DAT's authentic platform,
  3. Information Theft: The fake website's purpose was to gain login credentials. As users entered their information, believing they were accessing DAT's legitimate service, fraudsters captured these details.
  4.  Unauthorized Transactions: With stolen credentials, the fraudsters could then access the victims' DAT accounts. They proceeded to broker loads under false pretenses, using the stolen identity of legitimate motor carriers.

This case highlights several critical points:

  • Realism: The phishing attempt was highly convincing, using familiar terminology and a web address that, at a glance, could easily be mistaken for the legitimate one.
  • Technology Exploitation: The scheme leveraged users' trust in digital communications and platforms, exploiting a single point of failure—the human element.
  • Identity Misuse: By assuming the identity of legitimate carriers, the criminals could operate undetected within the marketplace, arranging for loads to be picked up by them or their accomplices.

Learning from the Incident

What can businesses take away from this occurrence?

  • Two-Factor Authentication - 1.3.24Vigilance in Communication: Always verify the source of emails, especially those prompting action involving sensitive information.
  • Secure Credential Management: Implement multifactor authentication and educate users on the importance of not reusing passwords across multiple sites.
  • Regular Security Audits: Conduct frequent reviews of platform security, particularly for systems like load boards that are integral to business operations.
  • Industry Collaboration: Share information on attempted and successful frauds to help others recognize and prepare for similar attacks.

By studying such cases, businesses can anticipate potential vulnerabilities and implement preventative measures. It's an ongoing battle against fraud, where staying informed is as crucial as any technological solution.

Looking Ahead: Next Steps in Combatting Freight Fraud

As we've explored the various forms and real-world examples of freight fraud, it's clear that vigilance is crucial. In our next post, we'll dive deeper into proactive strategies and specific actions your business can take to safeguard against these risks.

Stay tuned for more insights on keeping your business protected! In the meantime, visit our website to learn more about how our technology solutions not only provide an extra layer of security but also help you grow your business and maximize your operational efficiency at the same time.


Armstrong Transport Group ad highlighting freight agent commissions, technology, support, and a 'Visit Our Website' call-to-action with a smiling man on a laptop.

About Stephanie Wilson

With over 20 years of experience, Stephanie handles the intake and administration of cargo claims while also resolving emergencies such as hostage loads. As Armstrong's Claims Manager, Stephanie is also responsible for streamlining the department and fostering transparency in the claims process.